Moderator Note: This post has been locked to prevent comments because people have been using them for protracted debate and discussion (we've deleted over 300 comments on this post alone, not even including its answers).
版主通知:由于此帖子被用于长时间辩论和讨论(我们已删除超过 300 条评论,还不包括其回答),因此已锁定以防止评论。The comment lock is not meant to suppress discussion or prevent users from expressing their opinions. You are (as always) encouraged to vote on this post to express your agreement/disagreement. If you want to discuss this policy further, or suggest other related changes, please Ask a New Question and use the ai-generated-content tag.
评论锁定并非旨在压制讨论或阻止用户表达意见。您一如既往地可以通过投票来表达您对这篇文章的赞同或反对。如果您想进一步讨论此政策或提出其他相关变更建议,请提出一个新问题并使用 ai-generated-content 标签。This question remains featured because that is still the best (and only) tool we have to announce this policy site-wide.
这个问题仍然被置顶,因为这是我们目前拥有的最好的(也是唯一的)工具,用于向全站宣布此政策。
All use of generative AI (e.g., ChatGPT1 and other LLMs) is banned when posting content on Stack Overflow.
在 Stack Overflow 上发布内容时,禁止使用所有生成式 AI(例如,ChatGPT 1 和其他 LLMs)。
This includes "asking" the question to an AI generator then copy-pasting its output as well as using an AI generator to "reword" your answers.
这包括“询问”AI 生成器然后复制粘贴其输出,以及使用 AI 生成器“改写”您的答案。
Please see the Help Center article: What is this site’s policy on content generated by generative artificial intelligence tools?
请参阅帮助中心文章:本站对生成式人工智能工具生成的内容有何政策?
Overall, because the average rate of getting correct answers from ChatGPT and other generative AI technologies is too low, the posting of content created by ChatGPT and other generative AI technologies is substantially harmful to the site and to users who are asking questions and looking for correct answers.
总体而言,由于从 ChatGPT 和其他生成式 AI 技术获得正确答案的平均比率过低,这些技术生成的内容对网站及寻求正确答案的用户造成了实质性伤害。
The primary problem is that while the answers which ChatGPT and other generative AI technologies produce have a high rate of being incorrect, they typically look like the answers might be good and the answers are very easy to produce. There are also many people trying out ChatGPT and other generative AI technologies to create answers, without the expertise or willingness to verify that the answer is correct prior to posting. Because such answers are so easy to produce, a large number of people are posting a lot of answers. The volume of these answers (thousands) and the fact that the answers often require a detailed read by someone with significant subject matter expertise in order to determine that the answer is actually bad has effectively swamped our volunteer-based quality curation infrastructure.
主要问题在于,尽管 ChatGPT 和其他生成式 AI 技术产生的答案出错率很高,但它们通常看起来可能不错,而且生成起来非常容易。还有很多人尝试使用 ChatGPT 和其他生成式 AI 技术来创建答案,却没有专业知识或意愿在发布前验证答案的正确性。由于这些答案极易生成,大量人群在发布许多答案。这些答案的数量(成千上万)以及常常需要具备深厚专业知识的人仔细阅读才能判断答案实际上很糟糕的情况,已经有效地淹没了我们基于志愿者的质量审核基础设施。
As such, we need to reduce the volume of these posts and we need to be able to deal with the ones which are posted quickly, which means dealing with users, rather than individual posts.
因此,我们需要减少这些帖子的数量,并且需要能够快速处理已发布的帖子,这意味着要处理用户,而非单个帖子。
So, the use of ChatGPT or other generative AI technologies to create posts or other content here on Stack Overflow is not permitted. If a user is believed to have used ChatGPT or other generative AI technologies after the posting of this policy, sanctions will be imposed to prevent them from continuing to post such content, even if the posts would otherwise be acceptable.
因此,在 Stack Overflow 上使用 ChatGPT 或其他生成式 AI 技术创建帖子或其他内容是不被允许的。如果在发布此政策后,有用户被认为使用了 ChatGPT 或其他生成式 AI 技术,将实施制裁以阻止其继续发布此类内容,即使这些帖子在其他方面是可接受的。
NOTE: While the above text focuses on answers, because that's where we're experiencing the largest volume of such content, the ban applies to all content on Stack Overflow, except each user's profile content (e.g., your "About me" text).
注意:尽管上述文本侧重于回答,因为那是我们遇到此类内容最多的地方,但禁令适用于 Stack Overflow 上的所有内容,除了每位用户的个人资料内容(例如,您的“关于我”文本)。
Historical context of this ban originally being "temporary"
该禁令最初被定为“临时”的历史背景
When this ban was originally posted on 2022-12-05, it was explicitly stated as a "Temporary policy". It was specifically "temporary", because it was, at that time, a policy which was being imposed by the subset of moderators who were present on the site over the weekend after the announcement of ChatGPT's public release, 2022-11-30, through the Monday, 2022-12-05, when this question was posted. The moderators involved strongly felt that we didn't have the right to impose a permanent policy in this manner upon the site, but did have a responsibility to impose a temporary policy that was necessary in order for the site to remain functioning while discussion was had, consensus reached, and also allowed Stack Overflow, the company, time to have internal discussions to see what policies they would adopt network wide. So, after consultation with the company, the moderators present at that time chose to implement this as a "temporary" policy.
该禁令最初于 2022 年 12 月 5 日发布时,明确声明为“临时政策”。之所以特别标注为“临时”,是因为在 ChatGPT 于 2022 年 11 月 30 日公开发布后,周末期间到周一(即 2022 年 12 月 5 日,本问题发布之日),现场的子集版主们临时实施了这一政策。这些版主强烈认为我们无权以这种方式对网站施加永久性政策,但有责任实施一项临时政策,以确保在讨论、达成共识的同时,网站能继续运行,并给予 Stack Overflow 公司时间进行内部讨论,以确定他们在全网将采取哪些政策。因此,在与公司协商后,当时在场的版主选择将此政策作为“临时”政策实施。
Since then, quite a lot has happened. Based on the voting for this question, it's clear that there's an overwhelming consensus for this policy. The company has chosen that the specific policy on AI-generated content will be up to individual sites (list of per-site policies), but that even on sites which permit AI-generated content, such AI-generated content is considered "not your own work" and must follow the referencing requirements. The requirement for following the referencing requirements was, later, put into the Code of Conduct: Inauthentic usage policy. There's a lot more that's gone on with respect to AI-generated content. So much has happened such that it's not reasonable to try to summarize all of it here.
自那时以来,发生了许多事情。根据对该问题的投票结果,显然存在对该政策的压倒性共识。公司决定,有关 AI 生成内容的具体政策将由各站点自行制定(各站点政策列表),但在允许 AI 生成内容的站点上,此类 AI 生成内容被视为“非您原创作品”,并必须遵循引用要求。随后,这一引用要求被纳入《行为准则》中的不真实使用政策。关于 AI 生成内容,还有更多动态发生,如此多的变化使得在此尝试总结所有情况并不合理。
1. ChatGPT is an Artificial Intelligence based chat bot by OpenAI, which was announced on 2022-11-30. Use of ChatGPT is currently available to the public without monetary payment.
评论已移至聊天室;请不要在这里继续讨论。在发表评论之前,请先回顾评论的目的。那些不请求澄清或建议改进的评论通常应作为答案,或在 Stack Overflow 聊天室中发表。继续讨论的评论可能会被删除。– Samuel Liew Commented Feb 26, 2023 at 7:28
2023 年 2 月 26 日 7:28
已删除/锁定帖子/评论的评论功能已禁用 |